Search Historic Hotels in Fire Island

"The property was beautiful. The staff was amazing. They were all so welcoming and helpful. The hotel resturants were excellent. It was close to lots of shopping and not too far from JFK airport. We enjoyed our stay at the hotel."

"Outside the property looks decent, upon check in the girl at the front desk seemed like she could be a bit more friendly because she never once smiled and say hello. All she said was “are you checking in? I need ID and credit card “. Then when I went into the elevator it was old and dingy and noisy and a bit jumpy. But upon getting off on the 5th floor the hallways were awesome ! It was clean and smelled lovely and the light fixtures were pretty. When I got to my room the door looked new and no problems with the room key. Then when I got inside my room I was pleasantly surprised at how clean and spacious my room was! Everything about the room was awesome to me! The bathroom was clean and the shower was great ! The room had mini fridge and microwave! The double beds were comfortable and I rested well! The room had a leather spinning desk chair as well as a leather lounge chair and still had a lot of space to move around ! I enjoyed my stay at this hotel . The housekeepers do a great job with keeping the rooms clean and spotless!! I’d definitely recommend. The overall rating score for this hotel should be above 8.5, and not 7.6 because it’s lovely!! With minor issues like the elevator and washer and dryers that stole my coins. But it’s okay the stay was worth it considering the dingy dusty hotels that I’ve paid just about the same for and were disgusting! I would definitely stay again ! "

"Overall okay."

"Nice"

"Great places "

"It was a quick stay but very quick and easy check in, room was ready immediately and everything was clean. "

"Comfortable bed "

"We had to go to a family funeral, this hotel popped up, had very good reviews so we booked, very clean, bed was comfy, only thing was check out was 11 or 12 and we had room service try and come in after 8 am when we just got up, luckily we had the door lock on otherwise they would have not had clothes on! "

"Good"