"This hotel is in a great location and and Edwin was always very friendly, attentive and resourceful with transportation, recommendations etc. Would definitively stay again."
"This hotel is in a great location and and Edwin was always very friendly, attentive and resourceful with transportation, recommendations etc. Would definitively stay again."
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.
Wonderful staff and good sized room for one or two persons compared to square footage prices in Manhattan. Using the nearby Path trains does add an hour to reach the WTC for those with a Manhattan focus. In easy reach of EWR New York Newark, the Ironbound neighborhood for Iberian and Brazilian specialties. Close to PSEG, Prudential NJPAC and Prudential Center. Room was kept clean, but saw fairly heavy use of public areas during my stay. Explored via PATH grove street for Liberty and Ellis...
Wonderful staff and good sized room for one or two persons compared to square footage prices in Manhattan. Using the nearby Path trains does add an hour to reach the WTC for those with a Manhattan focus. In easy reach of EWR New York Newark, the Ironbound neighborhood for Iberian and Brazilian specialties. Close to PSEG, Prudential NJPAC and Prudential Center. Room was kept clean, but saw fairly heavy use of public areas during my stay. Explored via PATH grove street for Liberty and Ellis...
We've stayed there before and knew what to expect and they didn't disappoint! Always helpful staff, a great room (eventually) and a really good breakfast that sets you up for the day
We've stayed there before and knew what to expect and they didn't disappoint! Always helpful staff, a great room (eventually) and a really good breakfast that sets you up for the day
I really appreciated this hotel being my base. The staff were phenomenally friendly, welcoming and helpful. That made a big difference to me as this was my first time in NY, on a ten day trip alone. A big adventure. The mattress was firm (very important) AND there were feather pillows. Close to travel and amenities. It’s listed as three star. I see it as four star. Very good value for money.
I really appreciated this hotel being my base. The staff were phenomenally friendly, welcoming and helpful. That made a big difference to me as this was my first time in NY, on a ten day trip alone. A big adventure. The mattress was firm (very important) AND there were feather pillows. Close to travel and amenities. It’s listed as three star. I see it as four star. Very good value for money.
Jonathan
Reviewed January 27, 2024Reviewed January 27, 2024
Hotel is in a great location Midtown to easily access all the sights by walking and is 5 mins walk to Grand Central station for access to the subway and trains.
Rooms are very clean and well equipped with tea / coffee and fridge facilities.
Staff very helpful and friendly.
Well equipped gym with cardio machines and a good selection of dumbbells for weight training.
Definitely recommend this hotel
Hotel is in a great location Midtown to easily access all the sights by walking and is 5 mins walk to Grand Central station for access to the subway and trains.
Rooms are very clean and well equipped with tea / coffee and fridge facilities.
Staff very helpful and friendly.
Well equipped gym with cardio machines and a good selection of dumbbells for weight training.
Definitely recommend this hotel
Carl
Reviewed October 26, 2026Reviewed October 26, 2026
The Hotel was absolutely fabulous & certainly lived up to expectations , We had a suite on the 14th floor . The Housekeeping was brilliant & the suite was extremely comfortable . The staff could not have been more professional , helpful & informative . I cannot name them all but Barbara on Reception . Sergio & Zak in the Lex Bar & as we were celebrating a birthday we booked a table in the upstairs area of the Lex Bar & had the most beautiful meal . Nicely cooked & well presented & our server...
The Hotel was absolutely fabulous & certainly lived up to expectations , We had a suite on the 14th floor . The Housekeeping was brilliant & the suite was extremely comfortable . The staff could not have been more professional , helpful & informative . I cannot name them all but Barbara on Reception . Sergio & Zak in the Lex Bar & as we were celebrating a birthday we booked a table in the upstairs area of the Lex Bar & had the most beautiful meal . Nicely cooked & well presented & our server...
Patricia
Reviewed October 10, 2026Reviewed October 10, 2026
Very impressed with our comfortable room which was exactly as described. Comfortable bed which is a must after a hard day's sightseeing and shopping and the room and bathroom were spotless
The hotel was very close to Times Square, Central Park, Broadway and major department stores and attractions.
The staff were very friendly and couldn't do enough for us. Overall a great stay, can't wait to come back and would definitely stay here again. 10/10
Very impressed with our comfortable room which was exactly as described. Comfortable bed which is a must after a hard day's sightseeing and shopping and the room and bathroom were spotless
The hotel was very close to Times Square, Central Park, Broadway and major department stores and attractions.
The staff were very friendly and couldn't do enough for us. Overall a great stay, can't wait to come back and would definitely stay here again. 10/10
John & Anne
Reviewed November 5, 2014Reviewed November 5, 2014
Best hotel I have stayed at in New York from the staff to the gym to the small details they really go above and beyond. It’s pricy but you really are getting a luxury modern experience.
Best hotel I have stayed at in New York from the staff to the gym to the small details they really go above and beyond. It’s pricy but you really are getting a luxury modern experience.
I had a really great stay here. From the moment we entered and received a warm and friendly welcome from Chris who was incredible throughout to the day of departure. It was amazing that Chris actually remembered our names because the hotel was full and also had celebrity guests (due to the US Open).
Room was a decent size, very roomy for New York and regularly cleaned.
Some previous guests have complained about the cost of eating at the hotel - it is expensive but certainly not extortionate...
I had a really great stay here. From the moment we entered and received a warm and friendly welcome from Chris who was incredible throughout to the day of departure. It was amazing that Chris actually remembered our names because the hotel was full and also had celebrity guests (due to the US Open).
Room was a decent size, very roomy for New York and regularly cleaned.
Some previous guests have complained about the cost of eating at the hotel - it is expensive but certainly not extortionate...
Patsy
Reviewed September 12, 2026Reviewed September 12, 2026
We truly dropped lucky when we booked The Carnegie Hotel, our first time in New York.
On arrival we were greeted in a very friendly reception by Elijah and then by Alexandra who was a pleasure to chat to every day discussing all our adventures.
The afternoon wine was always fun and the complimentary tea, coffee and snacks were a nice touch.
The location is spot on. Central Park is less than 2 minutes walk, the subway is on the corner and Times Square is barely a 10 minute walk.
We will be...
We truly dropped lucky when we booked The Carnegie Hotel, our first time in New York.
On arrival we were greeted in a very friendly reception by Elijah and then by Alexandra who was a pleasure to chat to every day discussing all our adventures.
The afternoon wine was always fun and the complimentary tea, coffee and snacks were a nice touch.
The location is spot on. Central Park is less than 2 minutes walk, the subway is on the corner and Times Square is barely a 10 minute walk.
We will be...
Rooms were very clean and comfortable beds. Air conditioning was very good and staff are very friendly and helpful. We had nice coffee and snacks drinks in coffee shop 15dollars complementary spend per day. Very handy to central station and taxis easily accessed..
Rooms were very clean and comfortable beds. Air conditioning was very good and staff are very friendly and helpful. We had nice coffee and snacks drinks in coffee shop 15dollars complementary spend per day. Very handy to central station and taxis easily accessed..
Margaret Leslie
Reviewed September 30, 2026Reviewed September 30, 2026
Returned to the Peninsula after a few years' hiatus (I had an issue last time). It is an excellent place to stay if you want to be in upper Midtown. The prices can be quite punchy, but the restaurant and bar are not as mind-boggling as some, and you are getting a top notch product. The staff were friendly and helpful, and in the main not as overbearingly stuffy or as synthetically gushing as you sometimes find in similar hotels. It has a great location (5th/55th) so very handy for MoMA,...
Returned to the Peninsula after a few years' hiatus (I had an issue last time). It is an excellent place to stay if you want to be in upper Midtown. The prices can be quite punchy, but the restaurant and bar are not as mind-boggling as some, and you are getting a top notch product. The staff were friendly and helpful, and in the main not as overbearingly stuffy or as synthetically gushing as you sometimes find in similar hotels. It has a great location (5th/55th) so very handy for MoMA,...
William
Reviewed February 4, 2018Reviewed February 4, 2018