Search Bed and Breakfasts in Shelter Island

"Always an ama"

"Always a great stay"

"You can’t beat the location! Excellent property, a good value and we always choose it."

"The rooms were so nice! Definitely gonna be back!"

"Every time we go here it’s fantastic. The hotel is undergoing a renovation that will be completed the summer of 27. The rooms will have updated Wi-Fi and several other upgrades. This is still a fantastic destination. especially in the summer when you can sit outside and look at all the boats and enjoy a nice cold cocktail."

"The room was much larger than expected, very clean. Perfect location, Melissa at the front desk was very helpful"

"Excellent "

"Great place!"

"We gave stayed at Montauk Manor for the holiday for many years. The lobby area is grand and very festive during the holidays. The units are clean and comfortable with amenities that make it easy to eat in if desired. The front desk staff are helpful and friendly and the in house restaurant, Montes, is wonderful. We will continue to come on holidays! It is a special place. "