Search Motels in Lake Erie Islands

"Nice property. Would stay there again."

"Very nice"

"The shower water was very cold no hot water "

"We liked that this property was kept clean and felt safe during our stay. The only negative was the indoor pool. It felt very unsafe after seeing kids daily take a fall due to the wetness of the floor. Staff was very hospitable. The hotel is very well maintained. Food was also excellent. Would highly recommend and stay again. "

"Nice hotel being renovated by new owners. Have keyless locks, which is great, just have a passcode to get into room. Needs some good landscaping and they can turn this place into a nice little spot! Pool was nice, needs a little tlc but they got it. Employees were super nice and assisted with any of our needs."

"The stay at Castaway Bay was a girls trip for myself, my daughter and her daughters. The property superseded our expectations. The water park was big enough to keep the girls 4, 6, and 8 entertained and small enough to keep them safely contained. The daily activities were fun and engaging for their age. The staff were all patient and kind to the child customers. The overall stay was excellent. I will definitely do it again"

"Nice,quiet and clean. Fun time"

"My stay was great. The staff was amazing and accommodating. If I take my 16u travel baseball team to play at the Ripken tournament again in the future I’m definitely going to be staying there again."

"The front desk clerk, forgot his first name, Mr. Coffey, was the most pleasant, accommodating and welcoming person we’ve come across in our travels. My husband and I travel often, stay in a hotel over 30 nights a year, and we’ve never met anyone more friendly than him."