Search Hotels Near Gardiner's Bay Country Club, Shelter Island

"View is stunning but rooms feel dated. Bathroom is extremely tiny and terrace had uncomfortable furniture."

"Really nice property!"

"Great location! Very clean! "

"The room was spacious. I’m very clean. I was very impressed. Location easy to get in and out of highly recommend."

"Tara was wonderful and helpful at check-in, the cleaning staff was so nice and thorough, and the food at Nookies and the Boathouse were both amazing!! "

"Kaylee, John and the rest of the staff were helpful and patient. We felt like we were home. My daughter and I will definitely be back here to stay. We took many pictures and videos and will tell everyone about our stay here. Having a Galley on each floor was helpful as we had everything we needed within reach. Two suggestions, maybe get a peep hole for the room doors and have a microwave in each Galley so we don’t have to ask staff to microwave anything. Other than that, we felt relaxed and staying here made our trip just perfect. Little touches such as warm breakfast croissants, the candy bar (we seriously ate so many jellybeans and m&m’s this trip lol), the game room/bar area, macaroons upon checkout….we never felt rushed or like we were a bother. Can’t say enough about our experience here. Thank you, Thank you, Thank you!"

"amazing stay! "

"Staff looked tired,"

"fall season, pool not opened, been to Greenport before, weekends are best now, Halloween parade, plenty of small shops to peruse, bt check days and hours because of season"