Search Historic Hotels in St. Thomas and St. John
Change your mindBook hotels with free cancellation
Be pickySearch almost a million properties worldwide
Check availability on St. Thomas and St. John Historic Hotels
Top St. Thomas and St. John Hotel Reviews
Windward Passage Hotel
8/10 Good
"Good AC, clean room and friendly staff."
Mafolie Hotel
10/10 Excellent
"The view was to die for and the staff was nice. Food and drinks were on point"
Two Sandals – A Boutique Hotel
6/10 Okay
"We had to walk up the hill with our luggage because the taxi driver would not go up it. We thought it would be a good location because it was close to the dock to go to St. John. It was just 6/10ths of a mile but the walk was horrible because most of the way there are no sidewalks. We bought food from Moe's for supper and a good BBQ place just down the hill. Moe's has a buffet by the pound. Breakfast was as advertised, but some reviews said it was excellent. I'd say it was average with fresh made scrambled eggs, a meat, canned juice, and coffee. No decaf coffee or tea. The room was clean. The bed was fine. Only A/C in the bedroom but you could open the door to the living room to cool it. We let it be hot in the bathroom. I'd say I made a mistake booking this place based on price, but also no amenities like a swimming pool or gym. It cost $339 a night. We stayed two nights. I should have stayed in the place we previously had and paid for two taxi rides to the dock to go to St. John. We would have saved $328 minus the cost of the taxi going round trip and two breakfast's at a restaurant. I don't eat breakfast, but my wife does. If you have a car, there is parking. I liked the bench outside of the room we had because of the view. No real view from anywhere you would sit inside our unit. Nice view for breakfast. So, my review is mostly about value and not anything bad about the place. I gave three stars. If the price was lower I would give four stars."
Emerald Beach Resort
10/10 Excellent
"Great place to stay close to airport and car rental a lot of activities on the beach great views"
Margaritaville Vacation Club - St. Thomas
8/10 Good
"Great room well structured and attractive well equipped with everything you need for your stay the beach was full of seaweed but still attractive to seat and sun bath. Staff worked constantly to remove the seaweed but climate did not help much. Property is not in downtown so taxi or shuttle is appropriate."
Bunker Hill Hotel
2/10 Terrible
"Disaster! Filthy, AC useless, I have never seen dirtier, ripped, beat up property like this."
Cruz Bay Boutique Hotel
8/10 Good
"The staff was GREAT! Location was perfect. The room was clean but could use some upgrading."
The Westin St. Thomas Beach Resort & Spa
6/10 Okay
"Our room was not cleaned one day. They completely forgot about it. They offered a credit."
Lindbergh Bay Hotel and Villas
2/10 Terrible
"The pictures are a fraud. There’s no restaurant on the premises at all. The pool looks nothing like the pic. My bed sheets were dirty and had false eyelashes attached to them. There was construction done daily. Men were throwing large rocks down a shaft from 8am to 4pm DAILY!!! Including the weekend! They cut the yard daily. The excuse I was given was ground work was done daily. This made my stay horrible. The people were very nice but they didn’t solve any of the issues. I will never return."