We spent a week here, our first visit to Cartagena and really loved it! The staff at Reconquista were fantastic and the hotel is beautiful! We loved the two separate roof top patios, using each of them at different times. I actually really enjoyed the hot-tub on the roof; the first couple of days the water was cool, which made it a great soaking tub on hot days, but then later in the week the water was heated, and I was surprised how nice the hot water felt! I figured I'd want to soak in cool water, but the heat was soothing, almost like a massage.
Breakfast is very simple but good, and the staff is super quick, starting it up and bringing it out in courses after the second you come down to the dining area (there is no stated time for breakfast; just go down when you're ready). Also, there are only three guest rooms, so you definitely get individual attention and truly feel more like a guest than a customer.
We will plan to stay here next time we visit because the location is great, just off of the San Diego plaza. It was a fantastic deal and really went a long way towards making our trip completely relaxing.