Shelter Island Country Club

We paid a very low price, and so we didn't arrive expecting a five star hotel. It's older but nice, conveniently located, had very helpful staff, room was cool on a hot day, and clean with a comfortable bed. It's all we needed, and we'll stay there again if we need a place to sleep in the city.

Room was moderately clean, staff was incredibly short and unhelpful with an attitude most of the time. Breakfast was very crowded and full but with a large spread. Fairly central to most things.