Best Cottages Shelter Island in 2026

Change your mind
Book hotels with free cancellation
Treat yourself
Sign in to save 10% or more on thousands of hotels
Sign in
Be picky
Search almost a million properties worldwide

Check prices for these dates

In two weeks

In two months

In three months

In four months

Our top choices for Shelter Island cottages

North Fork Resort

Greenport

James

₹30,669 total

includes taxes & fees

9 Jun - 10 Jun

View all properties

Find holiday rentals that suit your style

Aparthotels

Condos

Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in

Top Shelter Island Hotel Reviews

Hyatt Place Long Island East End

10/10 Excellent

"Nice location near restaurants. Also liked the decor of the lobby which was welcoming and gave a nice coastal feel. Great breakfast with healthy options! The staff was very helpful too!"

Ocean Surf Resort

2/10 Terrible

"Sketchy. The room was clean & beautiful view. BUT, no one was on-staff to check me in when I arrived around 7pm. Keys were left in mailbox, ok. Not the worst part. Only 1 car there other than me when I arrived. Door only had a chain lock, no peephole to hallway, sliding door to ocean balcony didn’t lock & was only “secured” by a thin 1”w x .25” d piece of wood. 1 guy pulled up & sat in his vehicle for hours at night & best part, I found a CAMERA IN THE AC UNIT!!!! Definitely unsafe for females!!! Non-refundable of course so they can keep my $440 but I did not stay there. Went back the next night just to check & that same guy was in his car again! I paid for another hotel! BEWARE! Just a heads up."

Montauk Manor

6/10 Okay

"The grounds are beautiful and in the lobby are beautiful reminds you of old Spanish building. The rooms need major updating. The beds are uncomfortable and the pillows too. We found a few ants in bathroom. The did supply free car service to anyplace you were going which we liked. The bartender John at Monte’s was true gentleman. Made great drinks and gave us a history lesson about the place and montauk"

Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

4/10 Poor

"major construction would be ongoing for three of our four days at the hotel. Had we been informed beforehand, we would have made different arrangements entirely. The first room we were assigned had multiple issues: The AC was not functioning, and the room was 80 degrees upon arrival. The “ocean view” room primarily overlooked the parking lot, where delivery and work trucks created noise throughout the day. The door hinge was broken, leaving visible openings to the outside where bugs could enter. We attempted to contact the front desk to request a room change but were unable to get through initially and received no callback. After calling again two hours later, we were told someone would bring new room keys. Thirty minutes passed with no follow-up, and when I called again, the front desk member appeared unaware of the situation entirely but was able to send someone. While we appreciated being moved, the second room also felt poorly maintained, with visible grime on the side table and floor. At that point, we did not want to continue complaining so did not raise the issue. Additionally, despite my emailed request ahead of arrival (below), there were no extra pillows in either room to support my pregnancy. Unfortunately, the issues extended throughout the property: The gym was incredibly warm, construction noise was so loud it could be heard through noise-canceling headphones, and three of the five treadmills were out of service. The fire pit and shared outdoor areas were d"

Find out more about Shelter Island

Shelter Island Cottages information

Number of reviews	19
Accommodation	80 Cottages
Lowest Price	₹30,669
Highest Price	₹30,669

Frequently asked questions

Why book your cottage in Shelter Island with Expedia?

We think a getaway should be easy, so if you're seeking cottages in Shelter Island at an affordable rate, Expedia has your back. Keep the budget under control and pick a thrifty option far from the hustle and bustle, or book a 5-star cottage to pamper your favourite people.

How can I find cheap cottages in Shelter Island?

With Expedia's handy filter tool, locating cheap cottages in Shelter Island is easy. To discover properties that'll make your hip pocket happy, narrow your search by amenities, star rating and budget.

Explore a world of travel with Expedia

More ways to book

Book Cottages in Shelter Island on Expedia.com

Room 1

Change your mind

Treat yourself

Be picky

Check prices for these dates

Our top choices for Shelter Island cottages

North Fork Resort

Find holiday rentals that suit your style

Top Shelter Island Hotel Reviews

Hyatt Place Long Island East End

The Atlantic Hotel

Ocean Surf Resort

The Bentley Hotel Southampton

Marram

Montauk Manor

The Harbor Front Inn

Pier Blue Inn Old Saybrook - Essex

Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

Find out more about Shelter Island

Shelter Island Cottages information

Frequently asked questions

Explore a world of travel with Expedia

Search Cottages in Shelter Island

Change your mind

Treat yourself

Be picky

Check prices for these dates

Our top choices for Shelter Island cottages

North Fork Resort

Find holiday rentals that suit your style

Top Shelter Island Hotel Reviews

Hyatt Place Long Island East End

Find out more about Shelter Island

Shelter Island Cottages information

Frequently asked questions

Explore a world of travel with Expedia