I had stayed at this Shiloh a couple of years ago and thought it was outstanding, so I didn't hesitate to book when we needed a hotel near the airport for the night.
When we arrived, there were 3-4 groups of people standing around waiting to check in. There was one clerk staffing the front desk (this was right around 4:00, so the time most people check into hotels), and this poor clerk apparently had just started, couldn't work the computer, etc. We got in line and waited--I am not kidding--about one hour to get checked into the hotel. Okay, fine.
Later that evening, one of us decided to take a hot bath, only to find that the faucet on the bathtub was broken, as in it wouldn't budge and not water came out. I called the front desk and was told by someone that they'd be right up to "show me how it works." (I am 62, and I'm pretty sure I understand how American bathtub faucets work.) A half hour went by with no one appearing. Finally I called again, and a different person answered. This employee did come up to find that, sure enough, the faucet was broken. He went downstairs, returned, and handed us a different key, asking immediately for the key to the room we would be vacating. No offer to help.
This stay at Shiloh was almost (almost) comical in its mediocrity. And honestly, if at even one point, any employee had said "we're sorry for..." it would not have been so awful. Basic customer service is extraordinarily helpful in these situations.