Search Hotels Near Mission Church, Mackinac Island

"What we can only assume to most likely have been dried up bodily fluid on the sheets in the first room, completely ruined any chance of us getting a good night's sleep, and turned into a full blown nightmare when, after complaining to the clerk (Heather), we were transferred to a far worse room, with pee all over the toilet, body fluids on both chairs, and a gigantic, gaping hole in our blanket. I complained again, to which she called me a liar, and told me that my options were to either take the room or cancel my reservation, which would have left us out on the streets at 11pm in a strange place, with nowhere else to go. Absolutely the single worst hotel experience either me or my wife have ever had in our combined 92 years on Earth. My wife has been battling stage 4 cancer for the last 12 years. She is undergoing intense chemo and radiation treatment, and has a very compromised immune system. Putting her in an unsanitary, literal biohazard of a room like that is literally putting her life in danger. And they did that to us twice in the same night. If you ever have the opportunity to stay at this establishment.........JUST DON'T."

"Friendly staff clean room need routine maintenance knobs need tighting. Bathroom P trap needs removed and cleaned "

"The staff was very welcoming and the room was clean. Unfortunately the pool was a bit too cold. Breakfast was good considering we stayed in the off season, but I wish there had been more choices. "

"The room was clean, but the bed was lumpy. There were no bedside lamps so I bought one at the store. The fridge froze anything you put in it. There was no dial to adjust the coldness. We asked the front desk to send someone to fix it, but no one came. The room had been part of a car accident so the outer door did not have a key card access."

"My stay here was awesome."

"Breakfast was hot and very good. The attendant kept the area very clean and neat! The coffee was aleays hot!"

"This place was absolutely perfect to call home for the night! I went at the end of March so it was very cold and a lot of the shops were still closed for the season but I loved every bit of the island and this lodge luckily stays open year round which saved my butt! This place is clean, quiet, comfy, so so close to the water and right downtown where all the good stuff is! I’d stay here over and over again. The staff was so very friendly and helpful, we were thrilled with our stay!"

"We stayed in mid October 2025 and would definitely go back. "

"Very nice place to stay, it was clean and quiet. The staff was nice and friendly. "